Jump to content

Rosa

TMV World Member
  • Posts

    455
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Posts posted by Rosa

  1. emme207, I am going to explain what I meant before because I think you didn't understand what I mean: if you change famous songs very much, some people won't like it at all and can even perceive it as off pitch. Some others will see it as personal style and like it. This same thing can happen with the jury of the Voice and you'll have to analyze the risks carefully and make sure it is not perceived as off-pitch by people.

    Having a personal style is a great aim to have. It must be easier to achieve with your own songs than with others' though. It still can be done with famous songs, but working them very carefully. 

  2. She didn't sound off pitch to me in the other songs either... :) emme207, there's an important lesson to learn in all this since you want to go to the Voice or similar: many people (singers included) are going to see you as off-pitch if you make the song too much yours, so there is a risk in it. Making it yours is something to strive for in my opinion, and I liked that about your style very much, but we can see the risks.

    I've truly seen you as a fantastic singer all along, but I am afraid I don't have the tools to help you more. That's something Robert can do. So take the criticism as a possibility for improvement.

    Prepare something for the Challenges! I believe you still can sing something much much more difficult, something everybody can understand it is very difficult, like Barbra Streisand, Whitney Houston...some great song.

  3. I had given you the Like before I heard the second song, which is my kind of song! :)  (only saw one at first) You have a great voice. In the second one what fails is the mix between the music and your voice. I would like your voice a bit louder in the mix. But it doesn't matter...it still sounds good and I can see what a good voice you have despite the little technical inconveniences. :D;) 

  4. But it's not a teacher who is telling her that. It is a member of the choir, who is an "expert". We just don't know what kind of an expert she is. Some people think that by correcting others they automatically become experts, and then can sometimes do it just to keep on looking like experts. I think Felipe understood the situation very well, that the one who has issues in a casual choir like this, giving you such nasty comment, is that "expert". She probably would like to be singing alone. :D

    Anyhow, I think the best for you is to just forget about this all, since that expert is fortunately very far away from you in the choir, and keep enjoying the experience.

  5. I've only listened to the first because I had to download it to hear it. I disagree with your second comment: I think your voice has a pretty sound. And if everything in singing is subjective, the sound of a voice is even much more! I truly do like yours.

     

    I am also in a choir, in the lowest voice for female, and trying to be able to sing because the notes in the score are too high for me. :D

  6. Yeah! One brave person to take the challenge! Bravo! :)

    As I can't speak in the Review Section (nor do I have any interest in :D ) I'll give you my opinion here: I've liked your song much more since minute 1, like you were a bit nervous at first and gained confidence as you went on. It looks like an extremely difficult song to me because the singing goes on NON-STOP, with lots of changes in pitch (or however that is called that you have to do modulating your voice). It must be fantastic training for breathing, or you are already an expert at it, because your breathing didn't fail at any point. Just great. :)

     

×
×
  • Create New...