ronws

I guess if I could survive "Sugar" by Def Leppard, I could survive Balsamo singing a song just for the ladies. Trivia and a dark secret for me - I like "I've got a Feeling" by the Black-eyed Peas for the use of harmony. I liked Balsamo's version of "Gethsemane." And obviously, he's a success. He's the one singing it in a play, as well as appearing on Top of the Pops. Whereas, I am likely to appear in a ditch not too far from Steven (we live about 40 miles apart). I just approach the song with a little more indignation and anger from my own perspective and remembering Neeley's film performance, which appears to be not all that different from his stage performances, and less abject fear. And my age, too. I'm old enough to be Balsamo's dad, more than likely. That may influence me, as well. Neely, in his 60's now, In an interview, he feels that his decades of performing this role has strengthen his faith. And it has touched the lives of so many, as well. He said, at times, it felt like a ministry.

Steve, once again, you hit the nail on the head. How do you do that? For me, especially as I remember Neeleys' movie performance, he had angry moments in there and the mood I got, (which may be mixed with my own view of religion, now and then) is that the principal character has some doubts, some anger at what may seem like a needless event, even some indignation that this sacrifice may fall upon deaf ears. At the end is resignation, with just a slight sarcasm, hence my attack on the word "cup". So, yes, I think my viewpoint informed my inflection and emotion. In the video Jens linked, the performer shows fear and instability of emotions quite well. A wonderful performance. However, I understood the feeling of the piece differently and I think a lot of that comes from Neeley's performance and my take on that, as well as the way I would think that I would feel had I been Jesus' sandals. Even in times past, I have sang this song with somewhat of an angry tone, not for vocal effect to hit a certain note, but my interpretation of what is going on in the mind of the principal character. From what I remember of reading the Bible, Jesus was not a man who was afraid but he expressed love, and anger, at specific times. So, yes, something of an angry child. Well done, Steve and thanks for providing your astounding insight.

Excellent point, Analog. I call it the Simon Cowell effect. In his career as a talent "producer" he is looking for a specific "package" with everything having that polished Phil Specter kind of sound. A modern "Motown," so to speak. He probably would have panned Janis Joplin and the world would be a poorer place without her. Even I cannot imagine anyone doing "Born to Run" other than Bruce Springsteen, even though his voice had a rough quality. Bob Dylan's odd style totally fits "Like a Rolling Stone." "Jumpin' Jack Flash" needs Mick Jagger to sound "right." And I think mvrasseli has a better voice than those people, at least in this offering. Mv, you might suffering from the occasional hindrance of most any singer. The current inability to hear yourself as others hear you.

I know what you mean. When I choose monitor while recording, there is a delay of at least .3 and it throws me off entirely. So, I turn off monitor while recording and use just the overdub function which just creates another track and still plays the previous track or tracks. I take out one earbud. That way, I can still hear the music but I will sing toward a wall or flat surface in order to hear my own voice in relation to that. Other times, I record "live," in that I will just play guitar and sing at the same time but that is problematic, too. Again, I agree with jonpall. You are capable of more than you think you are.

Thanks for replying, Jens. I know my rendition was rough. I noticed other versions of this song where singers include more high parts and different emotional levels where I was going off the memory of Ted Neeley's original screen performance. I saw that movie when it first came out. And I had not sang this song in at least 10 years. But I will work on the expression. I've noticed in myself that the more I relax in a song, the better my expression and intonation get. I may have stiffened up on this because I wanted to hit the right notes and have some decent overtones, which are not coming through in my recording, and I had not rehearsed it nearly long enough.

I was experimenting earlier with different vowels at a certain pitch. Some vowels resonate in some spaces better and so have a different timbre. In the video that was linked, that singer is shifting between a fairly driven twang, with some distortion and outright falsetto. Not that you have to do that, exactly. But, for example, if you are feeling too heavy on 'ee' sounds, try to shorten length of those and resonate on other ones. You got quite an attack on the consonants, too. I liked your version.

I don't see anything wrong with having an accent on this song. Klaus sings with his accent intact and I think it adds spice.

It's a good recording and I think you did well. The pitch problems you said come from vocalizing in another room and not having feedback. That seems like an easy fix but I could be wrong. You have way better equipment than I have. Maybe you could have some headphones with a long cord so that you have a closer reference to the music. As for quality of your voice, I'm with jonpall. I don't hear anything wrong with your voice.

I consider myself something of a beginner, too. I still learn. I'll probably quit learning when someonne puts me in a box 6 feet under.

From the tonality, breathy or not, which I think was from moving around and unpacking, I think you are a tenor, so I must disagree with you. You are a tenor. A break or crack is usually just a case of rough transition in resonance. And, being here, you will get plenty of work on fixing that. As you said, you didn't do the higher parts so that you wouldn't crack. But I would like to hear you do the higher parts, crack or not. You have a lovely voice. I don't ever use the word lovely in conjunction with talking about another guy but I will make an exception in this case. Keep doing what you are doing and don't be afraid of a little more twang or crying, if that's what it takes to transition to the higher notes. I have been finding that using the bridging techniques offered here do not take away from your timbre or sound quality but simply allow you to carry your unique voice to a range that you need to accompish what you are trying to accomplish. Edited to add: I just re-read your post. I think you did well to sing it at the volume that you did. This allowed a sweet expression (there I go again with the flowery words) that might have been lost if you hit it like a metal singer. See if you can keep this edition going.

Awesome. Lovely vibrato, too. I can't think of anything but kudos for you. Well done.

Earlier today, I was youtubing Robert Lunte and found a vid of him and then another one of a student of his performing "Gethsemane" from "Jesus Christ, Superstar." I used to sing all parts of this opera for practice, back in the early 90's. I probably haven't done this song in about 10 years. But I was so inspired by their performances that I just had to try. I rehearsed the vocals to the store and back. Came home, took one practice run-through to remember the chords. The original sheet music I had started it out in the key of Eb(minor). So, the guitar is one take. The vocal track is a second take. And I still overload the mic. On the high notes, I have the mic 2 feet away from me and I still flattened the mic. And thank you Robert Lunte for the inspiration of this song and your performance had so much emotion in addition to technical prowess.

That's a great rendition and your voice is strong on the louder parts. It sounded like, in the beginning, where you are singing with a softer volume that you were a little breathy. Second half, it sounded more supported on the "softer" parts. And wise choice in vowel for the transition into the song's bridge.

Sorry, Steve, I didn't mean to mispeak. The image I have in mind is contraction even if that's not what's happening. The reason being is that, to me, and I could be wrong but the image helps me mentally, is that a high not is a small note, properly resonated and supported. Most times, a contraction tightens things up. It's part of the guitar analogy, I think, that would make me think that. On a guitar, you do make the string shorter by pressing on a fret. But then, as I have mentioned before, I know the guitar is not accurate, our voices are more like variable reeds. Anyway, my bad.

I listened a 4th time and, dang it, jonpall was right. The weak spots were your vowel intonations. I couldn't put my finger on it until he mentioned. Born to speaking english, I never thought of it. Where you are strongest is when the vowell forms in the back the mouth, just about behind the sinus, counterintuitive as that may sound. It weakens when you form the vowell forward in the mouth, such as on the word "game." It is a very subtle distinction and thanks to jonpall for catching that. Man, jonpall, you've got a great ear. Maybe, as you say, due to english not being your first language, making you more sensitive to vowel changes. I speak english, german, spanish and a smattering of russian and ukrainian and I change my vowel formations for those languages without thinking, mimicking a native speaker. I never thought about it in singing. And I think your point is well taken, whether we speak english as a first language, or not. That's going to be something I watch for in myself. edited to add: I know some castillian spanish but what I often speak is what we call tex-mex, a variation of mexican spanish that includes english words converted to spanish. For example, truck in tex-mex is trucka and lunch is lunchera. Malissimo in castillian spanish becomes mala in mexican and tex-mex spanish. Some structure still remains. "Que es hora an?" stilll means "what time is it?" As of consequence from having learned some spanish on the job, some friends have named me "Oso Blanco," (white bear.)

Bon Jovi is a band name and a business name / stage name. His real name is Jon bon Giovanni. I was using his real name to speak directly of him. I didn't mean to cause confusion. Bon Jovi includes Ritchie, Tito, et al.

I liked the timbre you had in this one. Quite similar to the original. You sounded more confident in the higher parts than the lower parts. Was this mixed voice for you or head voice? As someone else put it, these terms can be confusing. I've used full head tone and others have thought of it as falsetto. Either one could be right, I guess. When I hit a full headtone, it feels like a full head tone to me but might be falsetto. Or, it might be the other person hears falsetto, even when I am in full headtone. It's enough to make you dizzy. Anyway, mixed is where you have some of your "regular" or chest voice mixed with some of the resonance of the head. I think some are calling it curbing or crying. Where as full head voice could be a tight squawk or whistle-y note in the head or behind the sinus. Nowadays, especially since coming here, I often second-guess myself, so I may not be able to accurately comment on other people, other than as a layman who hears a good sound and try to describe it in the language here, as best as I can. It's only recently, like what I did with "Holy Diver" where my solution was not to go full blast and break glass with a sonic assault. But, instead, to go softer, or with a different tone. I think there's a timbre shift when you hit the lower notes but that might be my ear failing me or a trick of the recording. I was wondering if the notes you felt shaky on might be better approached with more crying rasp than even you used in this recording. I don't know, I just liked what you did.

You have an even tone all the way through. Kind of a Steve Earle vibe is the nearest comparison I can make. You sounded hesitant in register shifts. You hit the note on pitch but held back a little. Your best transition was the use of the word "so" as a slide to the next elevation of melody. It allows you to start whereever and float up to it. I can't find any fault but I was thinking that if you went a little nasally or twangy when you transitioned to the higher parts of the melody, it would give it some bite and it might ease your transition. Either that, or slide like you did at approximately the third quarter of the song.

Thanks, Fahim. I have sung it as he performed it but it comes out wrong on my equipment. It's one of the reasons I changed the beginning and ending to falsetto. And the guitar arrangement is something I came up with, impromptu. I had not played it quite this way before. The high part near the end "Sole survivor, you're the one that's clean" was always a bit rough for me as something of a passagio. I "solved" it by making the transition in range in falsetto tone and bring in the next repetition at full voice. Some might consider that cheating but look at the results. A recording that has received a favorable review. I have not sung that song in a few months but it's part of my practice repertoire. It's also a good chance to show more tonal and vibrato qualities I have in my voice that are not often found in the staccato lyrics of say, AC/DC.

Thanks for the technical info. You know, I think back to how you sound, even on "Bat out of Hell" and there is definitely an operatic influence, even if you weren't going for that. As for having multiple ranges, I think that is more possible in pop and rock because of the style of resonance. Surely, you can tell the difference between you and Rob Halford of Judas Priest. Part of that is due to how you resonate notes. One of the best singers to ever vary resonance for different effects is Ronnie James Dio. You can see it in his face. In addition to his moves and costumes being similar to an actor in an opera, you can watch how he moves his lips and mouth to create certain tones of resonance, just as one does in opera. The proof is in the pudding, so to speak. Can you hear the difference between how you sound and how Jon bon Giovanni sounds? I was plucking on the guitar just now to get an idea of the transition you are talking about in your previous post. I think having a passagio at or around F4 is possible and I think you might be able to hit that note, seeing what I can of your different resonances and registers in your submissions. I know I could hit F4 but not softly and not with an operatic timbre. I could probably do it in full volume falsetto or even a bit of metal timbre but that might be due to my physical limitations. And my voice has changed over the years. In the beginning, to hit high C, I might have been doing a metal-type croak. Now, I can hit the note cleanly, which may sound like falsetto but certainly doesn't feel like it when I am doing it. And it's hard for me to relate to others such as yourself what it sounds like because of the limitations I have with recording equipment. In person, I know I have some overtones, even in mixed voice, that you just can't get from the recordings I have put up. Would you have the luck at say F4 that you had at high C, for example? That's a tougher question. There's a physical limit based the shortest length an adult male can contract his chords to and still make a sound. For lack of a better description, I think it's logarithmic. That is, the change from being comfortable finally at high C to being comfortable at F4 is going to be very subtle, I think. How do you get there? Sheesh, you could probably teach me about singing and technique. I just know what's worked for me. I guess what I am saying is, how important is it to get to that note? You may end up changing resonance and timbre to get it and that would take you away from the operatic sound, at least for a while. Please forgive my layman's command of the terminology.

"Holy Diver" from the phenomenal Ronnie James Dio. I don't him justice but I love this song and wanted to share it. In fact, the beginning and the ending are falsetto for the effect of emotion, rather than worrying if I sound like RJD. Blessings to the all of us aspiring vocalists and to the family and friends of Ronnie James Dio (1942 - 2010).

I lack the technical ability to describe mid tenor though I could say that it is what I think of in say, the singing of Jon bon Giovanni. As for falsetto, there are some notes I am hitting that sound like falsetto on cheap recording equipment and other times, I know it's falsetto with lots of volume, akin to Justin Hawkins of The Darkness. And I may be ill prepared or qualified to truly help you but I wanted to give my input as a layman. Again, I am not a vocal coach or professional voice teacher in any stretch of the imagination. I am an electrician who has sun "I don't believe in love" by Queensryche, a capella, while making wire junctions in a junction box. And my friend, John, a hugely devoted Queensryche fan, had no complaints. What I can say is that it depends on the material, to some extent. I believe, unless someone will correct me (which won't hurt my feelings) that some sounds and lyrics or word shapes are easier to sing in passagio than others. But really, I liked everything you did. I do listen to opera sometimes, mainly arias. One of my favorite voices in the world is Sarah Brightman. She gives me chills down my spine.

This is "Come, Sail Away" by Styx. One of my favorites of theirs. I came up with this arrangement for guitar, pretty much on the spot. Then put acoustic eq on it. Nothing on the voice. But partially through, I backed off the mic a bit, which sounds like a volume change. The last note sounds like falsetto at full volume and kind of felt like it. Immediately after I was done I thought of a grittier note but oh well, nothing like maxing out the mic and the channel waveguide. Many people thought Tommy Shaw sang this. He did not. He was more of gritty singer. It was the other guy, Dennis DeYoung, who also sang "Mr. Roboto." Tommy Shaw sang on songs like "Renegade."

My version of "Long way to the Top (if you want to rock and roll)" by AC/DC. It's an easier song to sing than most. Essentially, a recitative over the music. Please excuse the timing. I did each track in one take and I'm used to playing and singing at the same time. And the tempo changed. I should fire that guitar player. Wait a minute, that was me. This song is for all you people here, whether you plan to be the next Rob Halford or just enjoy making music.

Here's my version of "Highway to Hell." I like to call it the Texas hick version because I sound like a country boy hick on it, I think, from the way we pronounce the word "highway" in Texas. I don't sound like Bon Scott or Brian Johnson. I do have to admit some of the tones, thanks to me overdriving the mic, are similar to that of Justin Hawkins. That doesn't offend me. And I don't know how to sing this song softly in order to get the rasp or grit that others get. I do get my own grit, though. This song has always sounded to me to a rough song, not refined, worn and loose at the edges, indeed, on the highway to hell. the laconic beat, even Scott's "devil may care" attitude. Angus's solo is slow and lazy. Those are the emotions I'm trying to convey. I used an acoustic eq on the guitar track and an inverted RIAA eq on the voice. Sometimes the eq helps, sometimes it doesn't. For example, I think the inverted RIAA made me sound breathy on this, when I actually wasn't. More often than not, I end up leaving the voice like it is but I wanted to experiment with this one and see how it translates from 32 bit 41k down to 16 bit wav and over to what youtube can play.